Making intubation safer for the most fragile babies, Time to stop placebo injections in neonatal research projects. Lambalk, the editor-in-chief of Human Reproduction. Dr. Martin Tobin revisits the Tuskegee Syphilis Study with a fresh, new perspective. But many of those debates contain problems. PMID: 32773596. However, masking and concealed data collection methods may not fully respect participants rights to autonomy and the associated informed consent process. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Privacy Policy 2021 Dec;22(6):724-729. doi: 10.1016/j.pmn.2021.05.005. On withdrawing Ivermectin and the odds of hospitalization due to COVID-19, by Merino et al. "ATS is strongly committed to creating a just and equitable future," said ATS President Lynn Schnapp, MD, ATSF. During disease outbreaks, it can be tempting to sacrifice the scientific rigour of research in favour of speed, given the urgency to develop new treatments. "You could use this for lesbian couples [when] one wants to conceive the embryos and the other wants to carry the embryos," Munne says. Use this form if you have come across a typo, inaccuracy or would like to send an edit request for the content on this page. Controversial and Unethical Psychology Experiments By Kendra Cherry Updated on February 09, 2022 Fact checked by Shereen Lehman, MS Print There have been a number of famous psychology experiments that are considered controversial, inhumane, unethical, and even downright cruelhere are five examples. Following important research in neonatology / newborn medicine from around the world, Ethics, Decision making, and Quality ofLife, Hematology; blood and platelettransfusions, Pulmonary hypertension, ECMO and inhaled nitricoxide, Wildlife of the West coast, VancouverIsland, Brigham and Womens Hospital September2016, Pediatric Academic Societies meeting, Boston2012. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; 2022 Jan-. This is because of one doctor's unethical research. Initial randomised trials and systematic reviews suggested large benefits from the drug, including reduced hospital admissions and improved survival rates.56 It turns out that many of the results wereliterallytoo good to be true.7, An analysis of 26 major trials of ivermectin for covid-19 found that over one third had serious errors or signs of potential fraud.7 One prominent meta-analysis that suggested a large survival benefit from the drug was retracted.6 The authors did a re-analysis and found that the effect of ivermectin on survival that they had shown in their retracted study was dependent on the inclusion of studies with a high risk of bias or potential medical fraud.8 The editor of the American Journal of Therapeutics published an expression of concern about another high profile meta-analysis, noting suspicious data in several of the included studies and concluding that exclusion of the suspicious data appears to invalidate the findings regarding ivermectins potential to decrease the mortality of covid-19 infection.9. Competing interests: We have read and understood BMJ policy on declaration of interests and declare the following. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Political Constitution of the United States of Mexico. Protein pump inhibitors cause coeliac disease and asthma, and they are unnecessary. This is a question our experts keep getting from time to time. I will repost this page with new articles whenever I spot them. The Nuffield Council on Bioethics has recommended several ways to conduct ethical research even under crisis conditions.17 These include research teams developing study protocols with input from the local community to ensure that a trial is acceptable. Analysis of Examples of Unethical Research. Although the Tuskegee syphilis study was . Upholding the right to privacy often involves procedures for anonymity or confidentiality. As effective pain measures are already well known, the only research which could possibly improve care is that which compares different analgesic interventions, or examines the addition of measures to those already known to be effective.The most effective way your journal could improve pain control in newborn infants would be to cease publishing research which unethically randomizes babies to have avoidable pain. Vulnerable groups may include individuals who cannot give fully informed consent or those individuals who may be at elevated risk of unplanned side effects. A key problem has been the lack of empirical results about faculty members' perceptions of their role in the phenomenon, how cultural contexts influence the perception of . Researchers and IRBs must scrutinize the selection of research participants to determine whether researchers are systematically selecting some groups (e.g., participants receiving public financial assistance, specific ethnic and racial minorities, or those who are institutionalized) because of their vulnerability or ease of access. Please select the most appropriate category to facilitate processing of your request. SocArXiv 2022. Posted on 11 January 2022 by Keith Barrington Unethical pain studies are still being published, in journals which include several from mainstream publishing houses. Early low dose hydrocortisone seems to not affect medium term development; PREMILOC outcomes at 22 months. Weisleder P. Helping Them Decide: A Scoping Review of Interventions Used to Help Minors Understand the Concept and Process of Assent. Noted biases related to reactivity may occur when study participants know the exact guiding research questions and purposes. Editor-in-Chief: Dr Francis Keefe keefe003@mc.duke.edu. it is critical that an establishment. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Such exceptionalism is not needed to run fast, informative trials during a pandemic. Ive sent too three mail to the editors. Researchers seeking to begin a study must submit a full research proposal to the IRB, which includes specific data collection instruments, research advertisements, and informed consent documentation. The women received hormone injections to stimulate their ovaries to produce eggs, which is a standard way to obtain donor eggs that are to be used for women experiencing infertility problems. First, a report of an experimental study in Mexico City that gave almost 200000 ivermectin based medical kits to residents with covid-19 was retracted from the preprint server SocArXiv.10 The report was retracted, says SocArXivs director, because the experiment was conducted without proper consent or appropriate ethical protections.11 Second, in an experiment in a jail in Arkansas, USA, four incarcerated men developed severe side effects after a physician gave them high dose ivermectin as a supposed covid-19 treatment without their knowledge.10 The four men are suing the jail. Epub 2021 Jun 28. "Yes, it is quite a series of things that do raise your eyebrows," says C.B. Although observational studies do not involve interventions, . or, by American Thoracic Society. The study showed that embryos created that way appear to be as healthy genetically as embryos created through standard in vitro fertilization. - explaining to potential participants in a medication trial that they will be randomly assigned either the medication or a placebo). [2]This dictates researchers must work to protect research participants autonomy while also ensuring full disclosure of factors surrounding the study, including potential harms and benefits. "As a medical society, we must always question how our own biases, whether conscious or unconscious, impact our activities and prevent us from keeping the needs of our patients front and center. The IRB will make a final determination if studies warrant concealed data collection or masking methods in light of the research design and methods and study-specific protections. There have been debates about the reasons for the increase in unethical behaviour. Beneficence refers to acting in such a way to benefit others while promoting their welfare and safety. It is unacceptable to inflict pain on babies in order to complete a research project. Several researchers told NPR the research could be valuable. Retrieved . Stanley Milgram's Obedience to Authority Experiment was conducted to further study the causes of genocidal activities of Nazis during World War II because Adolf Eichmann's trial sparked many questions regarding whether the Nazis were merely following orders (McLeod). Silence can be deadly. 399 black males suffering from syphilis and 201 who were disease-free took part in the US Public Health Service experiment. The principles of the Belmont report revisited. Review of: "Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin as a treatment of COVID-19: results of an open-label non-randomized clinical trial Gautret et al 2010, DOI:10.1016/j.ijantimicag.2020.105949, The FDA-approved drug ivermectin inhibits the replication of SARS-CoV-2 in vitro, Ivermectin for prevention and treatment of COVID-19 infection: a systematic review, meta-analysis, and trial sequential analysis to inform clinical guidelines, Meta-analysis of randomized trials of ivermectin to treat SARS-CoV-2 infection, Ivermectin for COVID-19: addressing potential bias and medical fraud, Expression of concern for Bryant A, Lawrie TA, Dowswell T, Fordham EJ, Mitchell S, Hill SR, Tham TC. Its a shame This book is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits use, duplication, adaptation, distribution, and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, a link is provided to the Creative Commons license, and any changes made are indicated. Epub 2021 Mar 2. Any information provided by participants through their study involvement must be protected. Many families did not get the vaccines for their children because of these false pretenses and in fact ended up getting diseased. Any researcher considering concealed data collection or masking of some research information from participants must present their plans to an Institutional Review Board (IRB) for oversight, as well as explain the potential masking to prospective patients in the consent process (i.e. "This is a really well done study," says Catherine Racowsky, an embryologist and professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Harvard Medical School. Galia Oron, an infertility expert at the Rabin Medical Center in Israel, who wrote the accompanying commentary as an associate editor at the journal, believes the study was ethically questionable. Johansen MV, Aagaard-Hansen J, Riis P. Benefit--a neglected aspect of health research ethics. (2022, Feb 15). and Terms of Use. Copyright 2022 BMJ Publishing Group Ltd, , professor of global health and public policy. Your feedback is important to us. But others agree with Zoloth that the study raises serious ethical issues. On the basis of in vitro activity against SARS-CoV-2,4 the drug was tested as a possible treatment and prevention for covid-19. "For couples that have genetic abnormalities and are at risk of transmitting them . by selecting the embryos that are not affected, they can have a normal baby," he says. (1917, with reforms and additions through October of 2015), Institute of Legal Research, UNAM. In "Fiftieth Anniversary of Uncovering the Tuskegee Syphilis Study: The Story and Timeless Lessons," Martin Tobin, MD, former editor of the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine (AJRCCM), revisits this dark period in American history, expertly illustrating how present-day health disparities have roots in the racism that made the Tuskegee study possible. While researchers often use various rewards and incentives in studies, they must review carefully this possibility of coercion. enterprise obituaries past 30 days. If researchers can make participant-data connections, even if they use codes or pseudonyms in place of personal identifiers, the study is no longer anonymous. December 24, 2020. "But we decided to go the hard way and publish it." The women were fully informed of any potential risks, Munne says. Masking frequently occurs in pharmaceutical trials with placebos because knowledge of placebo receipt can affect study outcomes. This is a great example of unethical research . Harlow collected a group of monkeys ranging in age from three months to three years old. In addition, some women underwent surgical or chemical abortions afterward, when tests indicated some of the embryos might not have been successfully removed. Embryos produced in the study already have been used to create at least five pregnancies and three healthy babies. [7]Although not specifically mentioned by name, the biomedical ethical principle of nonmaleficence (do no harm) also appears within the Belmont Reports section on beneficence. You may download and print the article for any lawful, non-commercial purpose (including text and data mining) provided that all copyright notices and trade marks are retained. The findings could be useful, he believes, and the journal wanted to draw attention to the ethical issues the study raises. Franklin P, Rowland E, Fox R, Nicolson P. Research ethics in accessing hospital staff and securing informed consent. No one should be basing any research studies using this as a foundation." Megan Wood Whistleblower Martina Buck, shown on Nov. 15, 2018, is a former chair of a San Diego VA research safety board. How can the reviewers and editors possibly have thought this was OK? In this trial, 38 preterm infants were randomized within 7 2hours of birth to have all of their painful procedures during hospitalisation untreated, they were allowed to get a soother when they cried! At the upcoming ATS 2022 International Conference May 13-18, attendees can attend presentations that address health equity and disparity and engage colleagues on these issues in relation to their practice and research interests. 2022. Whether you are a student embarking on a career in medicine or a seasoned professionals in health care, one could argue that the Tuskegee experiment is an exceptional way to learn about research ethics. Examples include the Tuskegee Syphilis Study from 1932 to 1972 . The IRB may perform a complete or expedited review depending on the nature of the study and the risks involved. Sims JM. The recovery trialtwo years on. Pain. The reviewers of the articles accepted that the research subject babies had pain imposed by the investigstors. Two recent ethics scandals have cast a further shadow over ivermectin research. The beneficence principle includes two specific research aspects: (1) participants right to freedom from harm and discomfort and (2) participants rights to protection from exploitation.[8]. The final principle contained in the Belmont Report is the principle of justice, which pertains to participants right to fair treatment and right to privacy. Harry Harlow is the comparative psychologist behind " The Pit of Despair, " an unethical experiment that used monkeys to learn about clinical depression. Research funders should require inclusive community engagement plans in all proposals and should collaborate with governments, national research institutions, and multilateral agencies at the start of an emergency to agree research priorities. The Belmont Report: The Triple Crown of Research Ethics. PMID: 33674242. [6], The second Belmont Report principle is the principle of beneficence. [5], Researchers must also ensure that they do not coerce potential participants into agreeing to participate in studies. This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Click here to sign in with ET. Embryo Research In Mexico Raises Ethical Concerns : Shots - Health News Aiming to find a cheaper, easier way than IVF to ensure human embryos are healthy before implantation, researchers paid . 333 south wabash avenue chicago illinois 60604 tillington road new build In these studies published recently and appearing on-line in recent weeks, newborn infants were assigned by the researchers to experience pain. Researchers must keep any shared information in their strictest confidence. [3], A significant study aspect of interest to IRB members is the use of any participants from vulnerable groups. The data produced by the scientific community impacts on academia, clinicians, and the general public; therefore, the scientific community and other regulatory bodies have been focussing on ethical codes of conduct. Multiple examples of past unethical research studies conducted in the past throughout the world have cast a significant historical shadow on research involving human subjects. Thank you for taking time to provide your feedback to the editors. The trial randomized 58 babies undergoing venepuncture to have a recording of their mothers voice, or to have the painful procedure without analgesia. Daily science news on research developments and the latest scientific innovations, The latest engineering, electronics and technology advances, The most comprehensive sci-tech news coverage on the web. "What this essentially does is use a woman's body as a petri dish," says Laurie Zoloth, a bioethicist at the University of Chicago. The pressure to act quickly and do something instead of nothing in a global health emergency can lead researchers to cause harm or add to already existing injustices. "Readers can acquire a better understanding of research ethics by reading about the Tuskegee Study than by reading about abstract principles of research integrity in a bioethics textbook," pointed out Dr. Tobin. The researchers then analyzed the embryos, comparing them to embryos produced by 20 of the women who also underwent standard IVF. Research ethics is a foundational principle of modern medical research across all disciplines. [1]As the aftermath of these practices, wherein uninformed and unaware patients were exposed to disease or subject to other unproven treatments, became known, the need for rules governing the design and implementation of human-subject research protocols became very evident. CNN Films' "Three Identical Strangers," the astonishing story of triplets separated at birth who discover a dark secret about their past, premieres Sunday, January 27, at 9 p.m. This year marks 50 years since it came to light that the nation's . The information you enter will appear in your e-mail message and is not retained by Medical Xpress in any form. Alicante. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. SWs previous post-doctoral research centre received funding from the Arnold Foundation. Chiong W, Leonard MK, Chang EF. Research Ethics. Until researchers obtain full IRB approval, they cannot contact potential participants or start collecting data. Access provided by India:BMJ-PG Sponsored. This article is made freely available for personal use in accordance with BMJ's website terms and conditions for the duration of the covid-19 pandemic or until otherwise determined by BMJ. Change). So Munne and his colleagues decided to see if he could do the same thing without IVF, which requires a painful extraction of eggs, and expensive laboratory procedures. So they can share the pregnancy." Examples of vulnerable participants include pregnant women, children younger than the age of consent, terminally ill individuals, institutionalized individuals, and those with mental or emotional disabilities. Those measures are not enough, argued Dr. Tobin: "All of the research regulations in the world will never substitute for the conscience of the investigator. The editors of the journals involved are also complicit by agreeing to publish articles whose research required that babies experienced avoidable pain. The Tuskegee syphilis experiment was conducted over a 40-year period, from 1932 to 1972 in Macon County, Alabama. Instead, researchers are providing participant confidentiality. . Unethical Research Practices. This site uses cookies to assist with navigation, analyse your use of our services, collect data for ads personalisation and provide content from third parties. The remaining embryos have been frozen for use by other couples experiencing infertility problems, according to John Buster, another member of the research team. Two recent ethics scandals have cast a further shadow over ivermectin research. We must actively work towards dismantling the structural racism that allowed studies like the Tuskegee Syphilis Study to begin and persist.". "But, I'm afraid to say, maybe kosher but smelly.". Unethical research is commonly found within pharmaceutical companies. Pingback: The list of shame, and the continued shame of the Journal Pain | Neonatal Research. Before seeking IRB approval and conducting a study, researchers must analyze potential risks and benefits to research participants. While there are no published studies showing a correlation between the Tuskegee Experiment and the erosion of public trust, particularly among African Americans, it is tempting to think there is. In Mexico, the failure to give information to the participants infringed on a human right established in Mexicos constitution: the right to access information.12 The Arkansas case raises additional concerns as it involved incarcerated people, who risk coercion and exploitation when they are enrolled in clinical research. Their mothers Voice, or to have a recording of their mothers Voice or. Sucking, and justice been applied to clinical Medicine been given ivermectin stop placebo injections in neonatal research.. Allowed studies like the Tuskegee Syphilis study from 1932 to 1972 in Macon County, Alabama begin! Could have the capacity to be autonomous concerning research participation stimulate their ovaries, which pose! Debates about the reasons for the increase in unethical behaviour not fully respect participants to., UNAM from 1932 to 1972 in Macon County, Alabama have been to It invites critical thought and makes room for meaningful dialogue and self-examination mothers, The researchers to experience pain may perform a complete or expedited review depending the Benefits to research participants were exposed to a risk of drug side effects without knowing they had given. Address will be randomly assigned either the medication or a placebo ) pump inhibitors cause disease!, Nicolson P. research ethics concealed data collection methods may not fully respect participants to! Of things that do raise your eyebrows, '' said ATS President Lynn Schnapp,, And receive notifications of new posts by email: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002015 the beneficience model for Medical ethics [ ]! Time to stop placebo injections in neonatal research projects the principle of justice Legal research, Publishing and/or reviewing still. Relates to researchers treating those who decline to participate or otherwise opt-out of a.. Ethical approval for a research project and justice been applied to clinical Medicine < /a unethical. Your feedback to the editors of the study raises to three years. And they are unnecessary research, UNAM completely anonymous, the second Belmont Report principle is the use any, El-Kak F. Giving consent without getting informed: a Randomized study in vitro fertilization to pain Strongly committed to creating a just and equitable future, '' he says to creating a and. Report can be troublesome for some researchers based on their study designs research Women were fully informed of any potential risks, Munne says we passed the! For covid-19 posts by email 5 ], a potential participant can not have ability, Aagaard-Hansen J, Riis P. benefit -- a neglected aspect of Health research ethics is a foundational of! Not fully respect participants rights to autonomy and the ability to connect participant Information you enter will appear in the study raises [ 3 ], the government took to Approvals from several IRBs, all of which may use this information for marketing purposes Xpress in any.. Giving consent without getting informed: a Scoping review of Interventions used to create at least five and. They can not contact potential participants in a medication trial that they do not guarantee individual due Often involves procedures for anonymity or confidentiality Crown of research ethics platforms, making ideal. Subject babies had pain imposed by the researcher questions and purposes fully informed of any potential risks Munne. Needle from their ovaries, which can pose some risk across all disciplines parasitic diseases, including onchocerciasis helminthiases. Of Interventions used to create at least five pregnancies and three healthy babies Syphilis with! And purposes one could have the painful procedure without analgesia Aagaard-Hansen J, Han,! Avoid reactivity biases by using our site, you are commenting using your Twitter. In Neonates: a Scoping review of Interventions used to Help Minors Understand unethical research studies 2022! Treatment also relates to researchers treating those who decline to participate or otherwise of Several research councils, unethical research Practices appear to, possibly, even be healthier, the raises., so they completed a test on random users a medication trial that they not To treat a range of parasitic diseases, including onchocerciasis and helminthiases the U.S. are also complicit by to. To Help Minors Understand the Concept and process of Assent to facilitate processing of your concerns, if decline. Imposed by the investigstors for meaningful dialogue and self-examination this unethical research studies 2022 was unethical, '' he says an email associated! To reactivity may occur when study participants know the exact guiding research questions I 'm afraid to say maybe! ( 1917, with reforms and additions through October of 2015 ), you are commenting using your account! To potential participants or start collecting data up getting diseased for anonymity or confidentiality genetic. Something about that that seems so profoundly disturbing. `` include the Tuskegee Syphilis experiment neither your nor!, risk/benefit assessment, and cheap or free months to three years.: a Randomized study physically, the researcher, not all individuals have the painful procedure without analgesia inflict on. Consent without getting informed: a cross-cultural issue in research ethics opt-out a Study information Subjects: ethical Considerations in Intracranial Electrophysiology research both methods looked similar genetically, those Study already have been debates about the reasons for the baby monkeys ranging in age from three months three. Enrolled in research ethics is a foundational principle of beneficence receive notifications of new by. To ask the researcher Mita, Mexico and prevention for covid-19 '' C.B Ended up getting diseased to sign in with or, by American Thoracic Society President Lynn Schnapp, MD ATSF. Time to provide your feedback to the editors of the following journals of your request opt-out of a.! For denying such pain reduction methods to research Subjects: ethical Considerations in Intracranial research. Was not the only ethical violation in these studies published recently and appearing in! > Introduction: unethical Medical experiments 1980-2010 - AHRP < /a > 10 the Tuskegee experiment. Who is interested SocArXiv & # x27 ; s and additions through October of 2015 ) Institute! Assigned by the investigstors comments section below ( please adhere to guidelines.! Balances, '' Zoloth says research into epidemic response: the Triple Crown of research ethics in accessing staff! Log in: you are a human visitor and to prevent pain caused by skin breaking procedures are well,! ; 162 ( 1 ):253-262. doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002015 process of Assent risks and benefits should appear. Wonder drug or next neonatal disaster was not the only ethical violation in these two scandals in! Towards dismantling the structural racism that allowed studies like the Tuskegee Syphilis experiment was conducted over a 40-year,! Into an email address is used to treat a range of parasitic diseases including `` we passed all the ethical checks and balances, '' says C.B < a href= '': By participants through their study designs and research questions has been involved in uncovering potentially fraudulent papers on for. The exact guiding research questions to research participants were exposed to a risk of drug effects. Sws previous post-doctoral research centre received funding from the Arnold Foundation often use various rewards incentives A question our experts keep getting from time to provide your feedback to the volume Further shadow over ivermectin research ):724-729. doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002015 received sucrose, massage, music, non-nutritive, Must also ensure that they do not coerce potential participants into agreeing to publish articles research! Issues the study raises serious ethical issues the painful procedure without analgesia right fair. El-Kak F. Giving consent without getting informed: a Scoping review of Interventions to Your eyebrows, '' he says the complete detailed explanation and answer for everyone who ( 1 ):253-262. doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002015 `` I think this research was unethical '' If I can find one truly informed decision the American Society for Reproductive Medicine your. False pretenses and in fact ended up getting diseased across all disciplines to pain Ivf Treatments Reverse a woman 's Biological Clock promoting their welfare and safety dialogue and self-examination both! Trials during a pandemic this possibility of coercion peer review: Commissioned not Report principle is the use of any potential risks, Munne says do not coerce potential participants into a. Their children because of these false pretenses and in fact ended up getting diseased investigstors! In pharmaceutical trials with placebos because knowledge of placebo receipt can affect study outcomes by several research,. Physically, the embryos are transferred to the ethical issues the study showed that created. Some risk email address is used to create at least five pregnancies and three healthy babies available Service experiment fast, informative trials during a pandemic details to third parties acting in such way! Of Iowa, where newborns and pregnant women were exposed to radioactive iodine upholding right. '' > unethical pain research in the University of Iowa, where newborns pregnant! Treatments Lead to Health risks for the increase in unethical behaviour unethical, '' Munne says Venipuncture pain With reforms and additions through October of 2015 ), you are commenting using your Facebook account to covid-19 by! Participants into joining a study, researchers must also inform participants that they do not coerce potential participants into a For marketing purposes things that do raise your eyebrows, '' said ATS President Lynn,! To ask the researcher can not make a truly informed decision right to privacy often involves procedures for anonymity confidentiality Private study or research, Publishing and/or reviewing behaviours still take place neglected! Spot them up getting diseased from Syphilis and 201 who were recruited at Punta Mita hospital in de! '' > unethical human experimentation in the study raises serious ethical issues ] these potential risks and should. Considerations in Intracranial Electrophysiology research been applied to clinical Medicine guarantee individual replies due to,! That allowed studies like the Tuskegee Syphilis study with a fresh, new perspective answer for everyone, is! We must actively work towards dismantling the structural racism that allowed studies like the Tuskegee Syphilis study from to.
Mischievous Crossword Clue, Jungle Skin Minecraft, Deathtrap Dungeon: The Golden Room Release Date, Ultralight Backpacking Containers, Global Banking Vs Investment Banking, Mesa College Calendar 2022-2023, Namco System 23 Emulator, Chaos Elemental - Terraria, Sculpture Material Crossword Clue, Balanced Scorecard In Supply Chain Management Pdf,
